UPSFedEx

Free Shipping $99 or more (Lower 48 states)

How Do You Know When a Pecan Pie is Done?

September 18, 2019  |  Kristen Millican

How Do You Know When a Pecan Pie is Done?

Pecan Nutrition

Preparing a pecan pie is easy, but it might be a little tricky to know when it is done so you can take it out of the oven. This is especially the case when it is your first time making pecan pie. It is important that you know how to tell when a pecan pie is done. If you turn off the oven too soon, you will have a runny pecan pie. On the other hand, turning it off a little too late means getting a hardened filling and crust. Either way, you will not be able to enjoy the crunchy pecans on top and the sweet gooey filling underneath.

When the pie crust becomes puffy, it is time to check your pecan pie. There are two ways to find out whether your pecan pie is perfectly baked or not:

1. Shake the pie pan

2. Insert the knife

Wooden bowl filled with pecans on a light background

The Millican Culinary Standard

Why the world’s most discerning kitchens choose Millican.

Three small trees with leaves on a plain background

135+ Years | America's oldest commercial orchard.

Logo of a shield with a check in symbol

Allergen Safe | 100% Pecan-only facility. No cross-contamination.

Green rectangular freezer icon with a star symbol

Cold-Chain Fresh | Harvested, frozen, and shipped direct.

SHOP ALL MILLICAN PECANS

Shake the pie pan

Take out the pie out of the oven and give the pan or tart tray a little shake. Shake the pie gently and, it should give a little jiggle in the center. The center should jiggle a little, but it should have some stability. If the pie filling shows horizontal movement on shaking, then it is not done yet.

Insert a Knife

The simplest way to check your pie is by inserting a clean knife in the center of the pie. Make sure to insert the knife between the pecans so as not to disturb their presentation. See if the knife comes out clean. If it does, your pie is ready to take out of the oven.

The baking time and temperature are two of the most important factors for getting your pecan pie just right. For baking pies in general, the oven should be preheated at 350 degrees Fahrenheit (180 degrees C). The baking time varies from 20-35 minutes, depending upon which recipe you are following. The internal temperature of the pie should be 200 degrees F when it is done.

5th Generation Owner

Meet Kristen Millican

Meet Kristen Millican

“Since 1888, our family has been harvesting Texas pecans from our Mother Orchard in San Saba. Unlike grocery stores, we own the trees, the shelling plant, and the kitchen, ensuring you get the freshest pecans physically possible to ship."

LEARN MORE ABOUT OUR 5-GENERATION LEGACY
Ebook Trigger
E-Book Cover

Create the buttery, golden meals your family will gather around for years to come.

Join 78,000+ pecan lovers for weekly recipes & specials.
Place holder

Why Millican Pecans Are Different

Compare the buttery, golden vitality of the Mother Orchard against the standard grocery shelf.

Features
Millican "Grade 1 Fancy"
Typical Grocery Store
Appearance

Plump & Golden. Large, intact halves with a bright, natural luster.

Shriveled & Dark. Broken pieces and a dull, "dusty" brown coating.

The "Snap" Test

Crisp & Clean. Snaps immediately, indicating high natural oil content.

Pliable & Rubbery. Bends or crumbles, signaling moisture loss.

Oil Profile

Heart-Healthy Fats. Rich in Oleic acid; feels buttery on the palate.

Oxidized Oils. Natural fats have turned, often resulting in a bitter aftertaste.

Harvest Age

Current Season. Shipped within days of the San Saba harvest.

12–24 Months. Sits in warm warehouses and plastic bags for seasons.

Processing

Pecan-Only Facility. 100% allergen-safe with zero cross-contamination.

Shared Equipment. Often processed with peanuts and other allergens.

Ebook Trigger
E-Book Cover

Create the buttery, golden meals your family will gather around for years to come.

Join 78,000+ pecan lovers for weekly recipes & specials.
5th Generation Owner

Meet Kristen Millican

Meet Kristen Millican

“Since 1888, our family has been harvesting Texas pecans from our Mother Orchard in San Saba. Unlike grocery stores, we own the trees, the shelling plant, and the kitchen, ensuring you get the freshest pecans physically possible to ship."

135+ Years | America's oldest commercial orchard.

Allergen Safe | 100% Pecan-only facility. No cross-contamination.

Cold-Chain Fresh | Harvested, frozen, and shipped direct.

LEARN MORE ABOUT OUR 5-GENERATION LEGACY

Net Orders Checkout

Item Product Info Price Qty Total
Subtotal $0.00
Shipping
Total

Shipping Address

Shipping Methods