UPSFedEx

Free Shipping $99 or more (Lower 48 states)

How Far Ahead Can I Make Pecan Pie?

November 11, 2019  |  Kristen Millican

How Far Ahead Can I Make Pecan Pie?

Pecan Nutrition

One of the best and time-honored ways of commemorating Thanksgiving with your family is to bake and relish a classic pecan pie. Traditionally, families across the length and breadth of the US have baked pumpkin pies, caramel pear pies, and apple pies for Thanksgiving. However, pecan pies started becoming popular since the onset of the 20th century and nowadays, the dessert is a staple, appearing on dining tables of many American families during Thanksgiving Day.

Are you wondering how to bake a pecan pie and how far ahead you can rustle up the sweetened dessert without sacrificing the just-baked flavor? Ideally, you can prepare the dessert and preserve the dish in a refrigerator at least a month ahead of Thanksgiving.

Wooden bowl filled with pecans on a light background

The Millican Culinary Standard

Why the world’s most discerning kitchens choose Millican.

Three small trees with leaves on a plain background

135+ Years | America's oldest commercial orchard.

Logo of a shield with a check in symbol

Allergen Safe | 100% Pecan-only facility. No cross-contamination.

Green rectangular freezer icon with a star symbol

Cold-Chain Fresh | Harvested, frozen, and shipped direct.

SHOP ALL MILLICAN PECANS

Baking and Refrigerating Pecan Pie in Advance

If you’re like most other housewives, you could feel that you’re running out of time, especially if you’re planning to prepare a variety of dishes for Thanksgiving. Of course, you can order pecan pie online or buy pecan pie from your local confectionery but there’s nothing like a homemade or home-baked pecan pie. Baking a pumpkin pie or apple pie for the grand occasion can be equally tempting but there’s one big downside of these desserts.

You cannot freeze apple pies or pumpkin pies well in advance for the simple reason that the original texture or consistency is lost in a couple of days. Thankfully, you can make and refrigerate pecan pies for a maximum period of 3 months, and you can bet the desserts would taste as great as they’d have when you baked them.

Grate the filling (of pecan) carefully into a prebaked crust, and allow it to refrigerate till it becomes solid and firm. It will take about 2-3 hours for the filling to fully freeze and turn dense and stiff. Ensure to position the plate (on which you place the pecan pie filling) on the shelf of the fridge’s freezer.

This will ensure that the pie stays even as it refrigerates. After about 3 hour, take the plate out of the freezer shelf and cover it up with a plastic that has been doubly folded. Next wrap a silver foil around the pie plate and put the same back inside the freezer for the entire period before Thanksgiving.

Take the refrigerated pie out of the freezer on D-day, unpack or remove the layers of plastic and foil slowly. Now, allow the pie to bake for at least half an hour more than the guidelines stipulate. Let the pie cool down considerably before you start slicing the dessert.

You can try out a myriad of pecan pie recipes for any celebratory event or occasion. Most of the recipes would require you to precook the filling for the pie and prebake the crust, so you’d need to be patient while preparing pecan pies. But the best thing about making pecan pies is that you can preserve them for a couple of months, and they’d still taste heavenly.

5th Generation Owner

Meet Kristen Millican

Meet Kristen Millican

“Since 1888, our family has been harvesting Texas pecans from our Mother Orchard in San Saba. Unlike grocery stores, we own the trees, the shelling plant, and the kitchen, ensuring you get the freshest pecans physically possible to ship."

LEARN MORE ABOUT OUR 5-GENERATION LEGACY
Ebook Trigger
E-Book Cover

Create the buttery, golden meals your family will gather around for years to come.

Join 78,000+ pecan lovers for weekly recipes & specials.
Place holder

Why Millican Pecans Are Different

Compare the buttery, golden vitality of the Mother Orchard against the standard grocery shelf.

Features
Millican "Grade 1 Fancy"
Typical Grocery Store
Appearance

Plump & Golden. Large, intact halves with a bright, natural luster.

Shriveled & Dark. Broken pieces and a dull, "dusty" brown coating.

The "Snap" Test

Crisp & Clean. Snaps immediately, indicating high natural oil content.

Pliable & Rubbery. Bends or crumbles, signaling moisture loss.

Oil Profile

Heart-Healthy Fats. Rich in Oleic acid; feels buttery on the palate.

Oxidized Oils. Natural fats have turned, often resulting in a bitter aftertaste.

Harvest Age

Current Season. Shipped within days of the San Saba harvest.

12–24 Months. Sits in warm warehouses and plastic bags for seasons.

Processing

Pecan-Only Facility. 100% allergen-safe with zero cross-contamination.

Shared Equipment. Often processed with peanuts and other allergens.

Ebook Trigger
E-Book Cover

Create the buttery, golden meals your family will gather around for years to come.

Join 78,000+ pecan lovers for weekly recipes & specials.
5th Generation Owner

Meet Kristen Millican

Meet Kristen Millican

“Since 1888, our family has been harvesting Texas pecans from our Mother Orchard in San Saba. Unlike grocery stores, we own the trees, the shelling plant, and the kitchen, ensuring you get the freshest pecans physically possible to ship."

135+ Years | America's oldest commercial orchard.

Allergen Safe | 100% Pecan-only facility. No cross-contamination.

Cold-Chain Fresh | Harvested, frozen, and shipped direct.

LEARN MORE ABOUT OUR 5-GENERATION LEGACY

Net Orders Checkout

Item Product Info Price Qty Total
Subtotal $0.00
Shipping
Total

Shipping Address

Shipping Methods